The Identity Crisis Behind Final Fantasy's Sales Slump

The recent news that Square Enix's major Final Fantasy titles have missed their sales targets is not surprising, given the company's history of overestimating its game sales. However, the issue with Final Fantasy goes beyond platform exclusivity and sales projections. The series has lost its sense of identity and direction, which is affecting its sales and fan base. The games have become increasingly disconnected from the series' legacy and the expectations of its fans. The attempt to reinvent the series has resulted in games that are almost entirely different from their predecessors, leaving fans feeling confused and disconnected. The success of the MMORPG Final Fantasy XIV, which has been well-received by fans, suggests that the series can still thrive when it stays true to its roots. However, the mainline series has struggled to find its footing, with games like Final Fantasy XV and XVI receiving mixed reviews and failing to meet sales expectations. The problem lies in Square Enix's attempt to make Final Fantasy a mainstream franchise, rather than embracing its niche status as a JRPG series. The company needs to re-evaluate its approach to the series and focus on creating games that are true to the series' legacy and appeal to its core fan base.