Hardcore Gamers Embrace DLC When Done Correctly | Opinion

The infamous $2.50 horse armour DLC for Oblivion is now 18 years old, and its launch marked a pivotal moment in the gaming industry's approach to post-launch content. Over time, attitudes towards paid DLC have softened, but a common perception persists that hardcore gamers dislike paid add-ons. However, this is an oversimplification, as evidenced by the enthusiastic reception of Elden Ring's Shadow of the Erdtree DLC. This expansion has been praised for its substantial size, scope, and transformative impact on the game, offering dozens of hours of additional playtime at a reasonable price. The key to its success lies in its thoughtful design, which caters to the game's existing fan base and provides a significant experience that justifies returning to the game. This approach is reminiscent of traditional game expansion packs, rather than the modern season pass model. Other notable examples of successful DLC expansions include Cyberpunk 2077's Phantom Liberty and Final Fantasy XIV's major expansions. These examples demonstrate that DLC can be well-received when it offers meaningful, high-quality content that enhances the gaming experience. In contrast, cosmetic DLC, such as costumes and accessories, has become a common practice in the gaming industry. While some players may view this type of DLC as unnecessary or overpriced, many have come to accept it as a luxury item that can be purchased if desired. The key to successful cosmetic DLC is to ensure that it does not detract from the core gaming experience and is priced reasonably. Developers should consider their target audience when planning post-launch content and choose an approach that aligns with their needs and expectations. By doing so, they can create DLC that resonates with players and avoids the pitfalls of poorly received add-ons.